The Best Tool Box Organizer, According to 5,000+ Customer Reviewers

Melissa Epifano Jun 06, 2021

Welcome to the Thomas guide to the best toolbox organizer 2023. Thomas has been connecting North American industrial buyers and suppliers for more than 120 years. When you purchase products through our independent recommendations, we may earn an affiliate commission.

What does it take to finally have a toolbox that’s organized? Luckily, not much. Discovering the best toolbox organizer is now incredibly simple—whether you’re happy with basic bins or fine with splurging on a more customized tool divider—and buying one means you can finally banish the inconvenience of having to scrounge around for the right screwdriver, bolt, or nail.

Image credit: Shutterstock/izmargad

Before you begin your quest to find which toolbox organizer is best for your needs, here’s how to pick one that will exceed your expectations.

Here is a list of the best toolbox organizers, followed by a buying guide to help you select the best toolbox organizer for your needs.

Thomas’ Top Picks for the Best Tool Box Organizer 2023

No matter what level of disarray your nails and screws are in, or if your wrenches and screwdrivers are in dire need of rearranging, these toolbox organizers will help your equipment stay neat and tidy.

Best Tool Box Drawer Organizer Bins: US General Compartment Drawer Organizer Set | Buy Now

Best Wrench Organizer for Tool Box: Tool Sorter Wrench Organizer | Buy Now

Best Tool Box Organizer Tray: Gripty Silicone Tool Tray | Buy Now

Best Tool Box Organizer: WORKPRO 17-inch Plastic Tool Box | Buy Now

Best Screwdriver Organizer: Tool Sorter Screwdriver Organizer | Buy Now

Best Socket Organizer for Tool Box: ARES Three-Piece Magnetic Socket Organizers | Buy Now

Best Hardware Storage Bins: Stalwart Portable Storage Case | Buy Now

Scroll down to read more about these top picks for the best toolbox organizer according to many happy buyers.

*Prices listed in this article were as shown in US$ on amazon.com (USA) as of April 2022.

1. Best Tool Box Drawer Organizer Bins—US General

This organizer is the best of both worlds, as it gives you basic sorting capabilities, but nothing too specific if you like to keep all your tools in one space. Comprised of three inserts that provide 14 separate compartments for tools and hardware, these bins are perfect for use in any kind of toolbox drawer.

You can store longer, larger items like wrenches, hammers, and screwdrivers right next to your smaller odds and ends. “Fit my tool chest perfectly,” one reviewer explained. “Everything is much more organized, and [it] made small tools and parts much easier to locate.”

BUY NOW: US$22.55, Amazon

2. Best Wrench Organizer for Tool Box—Tool Sorter

Wrenches from a ¼-inch to 9.5 inches in length can be neatly tucked away in this hard plastic tray from Tool Sorter that slides into toolboxes and chests. You can fit up to 20 wrenches in the main compartment, and eight in the smaller slots at the bottom. Aside from saving you room, the preprinted labels above each slot make the process of finding the right wrench quick and efficient.

“It’s designed to hold two entire wrench sets in as minimal space as possible and that’s exactly what it does,” described one review. “Hands down [the] most effective tool organizers I’ve bought; I feel like I just got half a toolbox back.”

BUY NOW: US$18.99 (Was US$22), Amazon

3. Best Tool Box Organizer Tray—Gripty

The color of this silicone organizer tray is so vibrant, it allows your tools to stand out (as opposed to a plain black tool tray) enabling you to find what you need in a pinch. The silicone material it’s made from is chemical- and heat-resistant (up to 500° F), and gives this tray extra traction, ensuring nothing slides out of your toolbox or work area as you port it around with you.

“This thing grips all kinds of surfaces,” wrote one buyer. “I use it mostly to work on cars but I have found myself getting it out to use even when at the workbench.”

BUY NOW: US$24.99, Amazon

4. Best Tool Box Organizer Box—WORKPRO

Sometimes you just need a box inside of a box to cut down on the chaos of a disorganized toolset. At just six inches tall, this particular box from WORKPRO, which latches shut securing everything inside, isn’t overbearingly bulky, so you can comfortably hide it away in a chest or box.

When closed, it appears to be a one-layered box, but its handle collapses down and it slides open to provide you with two sets of compartments—smaller boxes up top and larger cups on the bottom. “Nice construction,” reads one review. “I needed a box for all my rotary tool accessories and this fits the bill.”

BUY NOW: US$34.99, Amazon

5. Best Screw Driver Organizer—Tool Sorter

Similar to its wrench counterpart, this screwdriver organizer is tailored to a variety of tool sizes. At 10 inches across and 13 inches long, it can store 16 screwdrivers and eight bits in its raised compartment.

Several reviewers commented on the fact that many toolboxes and chests can accommodate two of these trays, making plenty of room for all your needs. “Nothing seemed to work until I found this tool sorter tray,” one happy buyer reported. “It holds various types of screwdrivers; slotted, Phillips, and even precision screwdrivers. This enables easy identification without confusion over size and type.”

BUY NOW: US$18.95 (Was US$20), Amazon

6. Best Socket Organizer for Tool Box—ARES

In the running the most annoying tools to find, and sort are sockets. They roll everywhere, get lost easily, and make finding the size you need next to impossible if you don’t have an organizational system in place. The three socket organizers in this set offer you 75 holders, ranging in size from 4–27 millimeters, and it even has room for a socket adapter, too.

Many customers admired the hefty magnets that keep the sockets in place when they’re in the organizer, and one explained, “While they do take up a bit more space than the rail type, they are worth the precious space in my toolbox. These are the best I could find that have the holes labeled. This makes for super easy identification when you need to find a socket.”

BUY NOW: US$64.68, Amazon

7. Best Hardware Storage Bins—Stalwart

Tiny bits and bobs are nearly impossible to keep track of if they’re not expertly organized. For staying on top of all your nails, screws, bolts, and other small parts, these hardware storage bins are a must. They come in four sizes, but the largest size, which contains 55 separate compartments, is undoubtedly best for those who are constantly replenishing their hardware supply. The latches and built-in handles ensure there will be no major spills and it is effortlessly portable and storable.

“I completely eliminated the clutter of random screws and nuts and bolts with this case,” wrote one reviewer. “The plastic is heavy and solid and I feel the clips will hold it securely shut.”

BUY NOW: US$21.04 (Was US$24.99), Amazon

The Best Tool Box Organizer 2023—Summary

The mystery of maintaining an organized toolbox can be solved with these seven best toolbox organizers, whether you’ll find the most benefit from ARES' three-piece magnetic socket organizers (US$64.68, Amazon) or the ultra-grippy Gripty’s silicone tool tray (US$24.99, Amazon).

Choosing the Best Tool Box Organizer—Buying Guide

Toolbox organizers are not a one-size-fits-all item. You may find that you’re in need of an organizer that works within a tool bag, a tool hutch, or a tool pouch. Your options are endless, but the goal is to separate your equipment and hardware, and in some cases divvy up the tools you use for specific purposes or projects.

While there is a breadth of toolbox organizers available, here are several common types:

Bins and boxes: These cubic storage types can be arranged in a variety of ways and work best when implemented in drawers, boxes, and chests. Plastic bins and boxes may come in handy for keeping track of smaller bits of hardware.
Trays: Easy to slide in and out, trays make it a breeze to view and access your tools, preventing items like wrenches and hammers from piling up in a corner, and they’re simple to clean too.
Foam: If you consider yourself to be an avid DIYer, foam is perfect for personalizing a toolbox to your needs, as you can cut, mold, and stick it in any formation you see fit.
Specialized organizers: These can be a mix of all of the above or made from different materials and come in various shapes. Specialized organizers are constructed for specific tools and supplies, such as wrench and screwdriver trays and dividers or socket holders.

We hope our review of the best toolbox organizers has been helpful. For more similar suppliers, including suppliers of toolbox hardware, tool drawer foam, toolbox foam, and garage organizers, consult our additional guides or visit the Thomas Supplier Discovery Platform.

Sources

https://www.mrhandyman.com/blog/2020/october/how-to-organize-a-toolbox-like-a-real-handyman/

More from Materials Handling

Materials Handling